FUTURE RESEARCH
The results presented in this study provide a wealth of information on
prescription drug use in the United States. This study used recent data from
multiple surveys, private sector pricing data, and outreach meetings with
industry representatives and researchers to provide a detailed examination of
multiple factors relating to coverage, utilization, and spending for
prescription drugs, particularly by the Medicare population.
The descriptive results presented here raise a variety of issues that
are ripe for further investigation. The study has revealed suggestive
relationships between demographic factors, insurance status, and prescription
drug use; however, we were unable to examine the interrelationships among these
factors. Future multivariate analyses will allow us to come to a more nuanced
understanding of these relationships. In addition, future research will explore
what can be learned from using more sophisticated definitions of drug coverage
status and severity of illness than were available for this study. Also,
ongoing analyses will allow us to continue to use the most recent data. Rapid
change in the pharmaceutical market requires that analyses be refreshed and
updated on a continuing basis.
Some possible avenues for future research based on the results of this
study include the following:
- What are the characteristics of Medicare beneficiaries
with and without drug coverage? Despite the wealth of
descriptive material we assembled on this issue, lack of a multivariate
analysis hinders our interpretation of the reason why some beneficiaries
maintain coverage and others do not. A particularly important question yet to
be answered is whether beneficiaries with the greatest need for coverage find
it easy or difficult to obtain it. An equally important set of questions
includes how stable prescription drug coverage is for those who have it, for
which people coverage is least stable, and the consequences of unstable
coverage.
- What factors explain drug spending by Medicare
beneficiaries? Our study demonstrated that covered individuals
use more drugs than those without drug coverage, but we were unable to provide
a causal explanation for this difference. Further work is needed to disentangle
the effects of barriers to access, adverse selection, and moral hazard in
determining the spending patterns of covered and uncovered beneficiaries.
- Can the appropriate use of prescription drugs reduce the
need for other health care services like hospitalization or nursing home
care? While there have been some studies suggesting that
medication can reduce the need for hospital care in the case of specific
medical conditions, there is little consensus among researchers on this issue.
Most analyses of health care spending tend to look at expenditures for
prescription drugs in isolation from other kinds of health care spending and
utilization. Our study did not address this question. More research is needed
in order to understand the way in which access to drugs affects overall health
care spending and the quality of medical care.
- Does drug coverage influence the type of medications
used? Do beneficiaries face barriers to
access to breakthrough therapies because of their lack of drug
coverage? Our preliminary findings indicate that there appears to
be a difference in the mix of drugs used by covered and uncovered
beneficiaries. We are, as yet, unable to explain that difference or evaluate
its significance. Further research could explore this issue through an analysis
that includes measures of severity of illness for particular medical
conditions, and focuses on specific therapeutic classes of drugs. Simple
tabulations, for example, suggest that different types of hypertension drugs
are used by those with and without coverage. But a more thorough analysis needs
to consider various factors (e.g., severity, coexisting conditions, race) that
affect choice of therapy.
- Have changes in the pharmaceutical industry and the
organization of prescription drug benefits affected the price of drugs and drug
utilization for covered and uncovered beneficiaries? Our
analysis of price information and discussions with industry representatives
have left us with many questions about how the industry is structured and the
dynamics of the pharmaceutical marketplace. Additionally, ongoing trends like
direct-to-consumer advertising or the continual emergence of important new
"breakthrough" drug therapies have been outside the scope of our study. The
complex set of interactions that connect drug manufacturers to patients will
require considerably more analysis to learn whether these trends will
exacerbate the differences seen in this report for covered and uncovered
beneficiaries. In addition, if more data were available on elements of
manufacturer pricing, such as rebates, further research could probe more fully
the differences in prices paid by different customers.
- How have the techniques developed by PBMs like drug
utilization review (DUR) and formulary management affected the quality of
pharmaceutical care received by individuals? Our study
draws attention to the way in which PBM management of drug benefits has
affected the pricing structure of the industry. Further research is needed to
determine whether these management strategies have had an impact on access by
beneficiaries to appropriate medications and or on the number of adverse drug
reactions in the population. Among the questions to be answered include: How
much variation exists among PBMs with regard to mechanisms used to screen
prescriptions for drug interactions and other safety issues? How are DUR
systems updated to incorporate safety information for newly approved drugs and
the experience with those drugs among the larger patient population? Is the
needed data available to permit timely and rigorous comparisons of competing
drug therapies? What effect will emerging strategies such as prior
authorization have on access to needed drugs?
- What is the pattern of drug utilization and spending by
disabled beneficiaries and beneficiaries in nursing homes and other
institutions? Our study, like most previous research, focused
only on Medicare beneficiaries living within the community. Yet beneficiaries
who are nursing home residents are heavy utilizers of prescription drugs. In
addition, while beneficiaries under age 65 were included in this report, they
clearly have different utilization patterns that we were not able to pursue
here. The prescription drug needs of these populations are largely unexplored.
For example, there is a much higher prevalence of mental illness among the
disabled compared to the elderly, making behavioral medicine a critical issue
for this population group. The disabled also do not have the same access to
private Medigap supplements as those over 65 years of age. Further work is
needed to explore the utilization and spending patterns of these
populations.
- What explains geographical variations in prescription
drug utilization and prices? Our analysis revealed striking
regional variations in drug prices faced by beneficiaries and in utilization of
drugs. Further work is needed to understand what factors are driving these
variations and what consequences they have for beneficiaries.
- How are changes in prescription drug coverage affecting
utilization and prices? Our analysis has observed a dramatic
shift in drug coverage over the past decade from indemnity coverage to
third-party coverage at the point of sale managed by pharmacy benefit managers.
A better understanding is needed of the effects of this shift, especially on
those lacking drug coverage.
- How do Medicare+Choice plans manage their prescription
drug benefits? Can their experiences help us to better understand drug
utilization by the elderly and improve the quality of care they
receive? The Health Care Financing Administration(now known as Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services(CMS)) (HCFA(now known as CMS)) has
initiated research to study the way in which Medicare+Choice plans currently
administer their drug benefits. The aim of the project is to uncover best
management practices with regard to improving outcomes, avoiding drug
interactions, encouraging appropriate prescribing patterns, and educating
beneficiaries about the medications they take.
- How prevalent is underinsurance by Medicare beneficiaries
for prescription drugs? The Agency for Healthcare Research and
Quality (AHRQ) has begun preliminary work to investigate the Medicare
population's prescription drug coverage. They will look at the way in which
different sources of coverage meet or fail to meet the needs of Medicare
beneficiaries for access to needed medications.